ⓘ Polar concept argument. A polar concept argument is a type of argument that posits the understanding of one concept, from the mere understanding of its polar op ..


ⓘ Polar concept argument

A polar concept argument is a type of argument that posits the understanding of one concept, from the mere understanding of its polar opposite. A well-known instance of a polar concept argument is Gilbert Ryles argument against scepticism. According to Anthony Graylings characterisation, Ryles argument can be stated as follows:

There cannot be counterfeit coins. unless there are genuine ones, nor crooked paths unless there are straight paths, nor tall men unless there are short men.

According to Ryles polar concept argument, counterfeit and genuine coins come in pairs, and one cannot conceive of counterfeit coins without also capturing the essence of the genuine coins at the same time. When one grasps the essence of one polar concept, one also grasps immediately the essence of its polar opposite. Ryles original argument 1960 runs as follows:

A country which had no coinage would offer no scope to counterfeiters. There would be nothing for them to manufacture or pass counterfeits of. They could, if they wished, manufacture and give away decorated disks of brass or lead, which the public might be pleased to get. But these would not be false coins. There can be false coins only where there are coins made of the proper materials by the proper authorities. In a country where there is a coinage, false coins can be manufactured and passed; and the counterfeiting might be so efficient that an ordinary citizen, unable to tell which were false and which were genuine coins, might become suspicious of the genuineness of any particular coin that he received.

A polar concept argument bears on some more or less strong version of dialectical monism, a philosophical doctrine that views reality as a unified whole, due to the complementarity of polar concepts.

  • polarity, absolute elements, pole and polar remain the same. Let P denote a projective plane of order n. Counting arguments can establish that for a polarity
  • kilometers 3, 959 mi Regardless of the model, any radius falls between the polar minimum of about 6, 357 km and the equatorial maximum of about 6, 378 km 3
  • freedom also known as political autonomy or political agency is a central concept in history and political thought and one of the most important features
  • Hernando de Soto Polar or Hernando de Soto dəˈsoʊtoʊ born 1941 is a Peruvian economist known for his work on the informal economy and on the importance
  • antithesis, and synthesis. Dialectic means that any ism which has a polar opposite, or is a special viewpoint leaving the rest to itself  must
  • constructors with the same argument types, e.g., to create a point object either from the cartesian coordinates or from the polar coordinates, both of which
  • A binary opposition also binary system is a pair of related terms or concepts that are opposite in meaning. Binary opposition is the system of language
  • his 1958 lecture Two Concepts of Liberty Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy describes negative liberty: The negative concept of freedom . is most
  • In physics, the concept of absolute rotation - rotation independent of any external reference - is a topic of debate about relativity, cosmology, and the
  • was a NASA concept for a Mars rover mission, proposed to be launched in 2018 together with the European ExoMars rover. The MAX - C rover concept was cancelled
  • the polar axis and the equatorial eccentricity is the eccentricity of the ellipse formed by a section through the centre, perpendicular to the polar axis

Users also searched: