ⓘ A Causal Theory of Knowing is a philosophical essay written by Alvin Goldman in 1967, published in The Journal of Philosophy. It is based on existing theories o ..


ⓘ A Causal Theory of Knowing

A Causal Theory of Knowing is a philosophical essay written by Alvin Goldman in 1967, published in The Journal of Philosophy. It is based on existing theories of knowledge in the realm of epistemology, the study of philosophy through the scope of knowledge. The essay attempts to define knowledge by connecting facts, beliefs and knowledge through underlying and connective series called causal chains. It provides a causal theory of knowledge.

A causal chain is repeatedly described as a sequence of events for which one event in a chain causes the next. According to Goldman, these chains can only exist with the presence of an accepted fact, a belief in the fact, and a cause for the subject to believe the fact. The essay also explores the ideas of perception and memory through the use of the causal chains and the concept of knowledge.


1. Background

The essay is regarded as an improvement and rebuttal of Edmund Gettiers "Is Justified True Belief Knowledge?", which is one of many attempts to explain the necessary conditions for knowledge to develop. Goldman implements the causal connection to reiterate his own theory of knowledge. Knowledge exists, says Goldman, if and only if the belief is justified by a reaction to the accepted fact.

Goldmans theory later counters that of Michael Clark, stating that his own theory including figures and diagrams is more appropriate than Clarks. "A Causal Theory of Knowing" uses figures which make explicit references to causal beliefs. Clarks model does not utilize these arrows, and Goldman states that the lack of these arrows deems Clarks model deficient.


2. Author

Alvin Goldman, currently a professor of philosophy at Rutgers University, wrote "A Causal Theory of Knowing" when he was in his late twenties. Goldman received his Ph.D. from Princeton University, and has taught at numerous universities.

Goldmans research deals mainly with epistemology and other cognitive sciences. "A Causal Theory of Knowing" was Goldmans first published paper explaining his own views of epistemology. Currently, Goldman has written more than ten essays focusing on knowledge and cognitive science.


3. Contents

The essay starts with a definition of Gettiers theory, followed by multiple reiterations of the idea of causal connections, figures to explain knowledge through a visual perspective, and references to perception and memory through causal chains.

The essay tends to focus on examples in which knowledge or other sensations do not exist, rather than proving a certain fact to be known. Goldman also states on multiple occasions that he does not wish to explain the causal process in detail, instead pointing out counterexamples. At numerous times in the essay, he also points out that he does not intend to give definitive answers to each of the propositions mentioned.

Goldman also refocuses the idea of perception, or knowledge through sensation specifically sight using his own theory of knowing. The concept of causal perception indicates that one observes something only if the object itself causes the sensation of sight to be accepted as known. Thus, the objects existence must be factual and one must believe its existence. While all knowledge comes from facts, inferred knowledge emerges when physical object facts cause sense data which can be perceived as senses. The sense data can also be used to make conclusions, known as inferred knowledge, about certain physical object facts.

From "A Causal Theory of Knowing", Goldman constructs the idea that memory is also a causal process. Memory is explained as being an extension of knowledge into the future, and remembering is the act of recalling a fact that has already been known. Further, the theory states that if knowledge is forgotten at one time, it cannot be considered a memory in the future. According to Goldman, if a fact is known at Time 1 but forgotten at Time 2, and then at Time 3 that the fact is perceived again but not known, at Time 3 the original fact is not a memory because there is no causal connection between the fact and the memory.

  • Causal reasoning is the process of identifying causality: the relationship between a cause and its effect. The study of causality extends from ancient
  • a process has many causes, which are also said to be causal factors for it, and all lie in its past. An effect can in turn be a cause of or causal factor
  • Applications of Cognitive Science, and Simulating Minds. Action 1965 A Causal Theory of Knowing in The Journal of Philosophy v. 64 1967 pp. 357 372. A Theory
  • Ghirardi Rimini Weber theory Penrose interpretation, or causal fermion systems avoid these absurdities. The theory of causal fermion systems for example
  • the descriptivist theory which is sometimes called the Frege Russell view. In the 1970s, this theory came under attack from causal theorists such as
  • to duality of structure The similarity of Giddens theory and conversation and text theory is a mutual - existing and causal relationship of communication
  • Cartesian Other Cartesian Self Catherine Elgin Causal chain Causal Theory of Knowing Causality Center Leo Apostel for Interdisciplinary
  • A Causal Theory of Knowing Journal of Philosophy, 64 1967 pp. 357 372 is generally credited as being the first full treatment of the theory though
  • The Theory of Narrative Thought is a theory of thought designed to bridge the gap between the neurological functioning of the brain and the flow of everyday
  • that causal influences cannot travel faster than the speed of light and or backwards in time. In quantum field theory observables of events with a spacelike

Users also searched: